Russia should respond to the situation in the Ukraine by following
the precedent set by the United States in a comparable situation.
Russia should offer to purchase the Russian populated areas
whose residents want to leave Ukraine much like the United States purchased California from Mexico.
In the 1840's people from the United States had settled in parts of
Mexico, but were not happy with the Mexican
government. U.S. citizens in the Texas
region had openly revolted and gained independence from
Mexico. People in California were also interested in leaving
Mexico. The United States annexed Texas and a border dispute
led to war between the United States and Mexico. The United
States won the war but instead of simply taking other territory from
Mexico forced Mexico to sell California and additional areas to the
United States. The United States also assumed some debts that
Mexico owed to U.S citizens.
The Russians in the eastern Ukraine don't want to be part of Ukraine
any more than the U.S. citizens in California and Texas wanted to be
part of Mexico. Russia should help them leave by offering to
purchase the region from Ukraine once the people of Ukraine vote for
a new government. Government officials chosen in an
election have authority from the people to act. Officials who
came to power as a result of mob action have no authority from the
people to act.
Russia should also consider compensating Ukraine for the its loss of
Crimea. The separation of Crimea from Ukraine was comparable
to a divorce. Often one party to a divorce will compensate the
other by paying alimony to the other/ Russia could undermine
claims that it "stole" Crimea by paying alimony to Ukraine.
Paying for something isn't stealing.
The mob overthrow of a president from eastern Ukraine and talk of
eliminating Russian as an official language indicates that many
Ukrainians don't want Russians in their country. The presences of
racist elements in the anti-government mob indicates the overthrow
may have been in part motivated by ethnic prejudice. Russians
in Ukraine fear that failure to allow the Russian region to leave
Ukraine could result in use of violence against them.
Failure to allow the Russian region to leave could lead to prolonged
efforts against the Ukraine government. European ethnic conflicts
[such as the Basque conflict in Spain and the conflict between Irish
Catholics and English Protestants in Northern Ireland] can
last for generations.
Americans tend to think of ethnic conflicts in terms of differences
in skin color, but differences in culture can produce the same
results as was the case in Adolf Hitler's efforts to exterminate the
Jewish people.
During the collapse of the Soviet empire, the residents of
Czechoslovakia recognized that they would have a better chance of
success if they split into two countries. Ukrainians made a
mistake by keeping the arbitrary political boundaries set by the old
Soviet Union. The Soviet Union to a large extent was a
Russian empire. Keeping Russian regions in Ukraine means
Ukrainians are still subject to control by politicians chosen in
part by Russians. Eliminating the Russian regions
from Ukraine would make Ukrainians truly independent of Russia.
Showing posts with label Ukraine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ukraine. Show all posts
Friday, May 2, 2014
Wednesday, March 19, 2014
Crimea Separation from Ukraine Best for Everyone
Contrary to the opinion of President Barack Obama there is nothing
illegal about the recent vote for the Autonomous Republic of Crimea
to leave the chaotic situation in The Ukraine. In 1991
the Ukraine separated itself from the deteriorating government of
the then Soviet Union by a declaration of independence and
created a precedent for the Autonomous Republic of Crimea to
separate itself from The Ukraine. The obvious instability
associated with the fall of the Ukrainian government justified The
Republic of Crimea's exit from The Ukraine.
If there was a recent violation of international law in The Ukraine it is more likely associated with the mob that overthrew the elected government. That mob closely resembled a fifth column like Nazi Germany used against nations it wanted to conquer. If the European Union accepts The Ukraine for membership now the EU will be implying it helped overthrow of The Ukraine government. If the EU accepts The Ukraine without waiting for at least two elections, not counting the upcoming one, the EU will imply it eliminated a government that opposed EU membership so the EU could conquer The Ukraine.
Requiring The Ukraine to first demonstrate it is a stable democracy that changes government only through elections will indicate that the EU recognizes The Ukraine's political instability makes it an undesirable member. The recent use of mob rule to change the government indicates the presence of a cancer that must first be isolated and cured before The Ukraine is considered healthy enough to be allowed into the EU. Allegations that some of the groups responsible have previously supported extremist views should be of particular concern to EU members,
The EU needs to conduct a thorough investigation of the recent change in The Ukraine's government so member nations know what they need to do to prevent similar events in their countries. The EU needs to identify any business individuals or non-Ukrainians involved so EU members will know who to watch out for.
Political instability such as that associated with the fall of the Ukrainian government can lead to ethic violence in countries with strong ethnic divisions. Without a stable central government, the Crimean Republic had to take over the responsibility of protecting its citizens. Separating from the ineffectual Ukrainian government made that job easier. Crimea's "divorce" from The Ukraine will reduce the potential for an ethnic centered civil war between the Russians of Crimea and the Ukrainians. Reducing ethnic tensions will reduce the demands on the Ukrainian government and simplify the task of restoring a stable government.
If there was a recent violation of international law in The Ukraine it is more likely associated with the mob that overthrew the elected government. That mob closely resembled a fifth column like Nazi Germany used against nations it wanted to conquer. If the European Union accepts The Ukraine for membership now the EU will be implying it helped overthrow of The Ukraine government. If the EU accepts The Ukraine without waiting for at least two elections, not counting the upcoming one, the EU will imply it eliminated a government that opposed EU membership so the EU could conquer The Ukraine.
Requiring The Ukraine to first demonstrate it is a stable democracy that changes government only through elections will indicate that the EU recognizes The Ukraine's political instability makes it an undesirable member. The recent use of mob rule to change the government indicates the presence of a cancer that must first be isolated and cured before The Ukraine is considered healthy enough to be allowed into the EU. Allegations that some of the groups responsible have previously supported extremist views should be of particular concern to EU members,
The EU needs to conduct a thorough investigation of the recent change in The Ukraine's government so member nations know what they need to do to prevent similar events in their countries. The EU needs to identify any business individuals or non-Ukrainians involved so EU members will know who to watch out for.
Political instability such as that associated with the fall of the Ukrainian government can lead to ethic violence in countries with strong ethnic divisions. Without a stable central government, the Crimean Republic had to take over the responsibility of protecting its citizens. Separating from the ineffectual Ukrainian government made that job easier. Crimea's "divorce" from The Ukraine will reduce the potential for an ethnic centered civil war between the Russians of Crimea and the Ukrainians. Reducing ethnic tensions will reduce the demands on the Ukrainian government and simplify the task of restoring a stable government.
Saturday, March 15, 2014
Russia Should Buy Crimea
The best way to resolve the situation in Crimea in the event the
residents want to separate from the Ukraine would be for Russia to
purchase the territory. Russia could then allow the
Crimeans to decide what status they wanted such as becoming an
independent state or joining the other ethnic Russians in the
Russian Federation.
I was going to include this suggestion in a post dealing with the situation in general but decided the proposal would be more likely to be noticed if suggested in a separate post. I believe the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo which ended the war between the United States and Mexico in 1848 suggests a resolution of the conflict over control of Crimea.
A dispute over whether an area (occupied by persons who identified with the United States) which is now the State of Texas was independent sparked a short war between the United States and Mexico. The United States easily won the war but then agreed to purchase another part of Mexico that was attracting settlers who identified with the United States. The purchase eliminated the potential for a future conflict between residents of that area and the Mexican government
Crimea is something of value so it would be fair for The Ukraine to receive compensation for its loss. The payment for Crimea could be thought of as compensation for money the national government of The Ukraine has spent on the region for such expenditures as government buildings or infrastructure items like roads. The payment would replace tax money that would no longer be collected from Crimea.
Payment wouldn't need to take the form of money. Russia has ample energy resources and The Ukraine already obtains energy from Russia. Thus, natural gas or some other fuel might be used as compensation. The Ukrainian government has had a policy of trying to keep energy costs down for its citizens. Russia might significantly reduce what it charges for natural gas for the next 10 - 20 years with an implication that the discount would be passed along to individuals. Russia might also offer to compensate anyone wishing to move from Crimea to the Ukraine or The Ukraine to Crimea.
Ukrainian officials need to recognize the potential costs of trying to force Russian Crimeans to stay in a country where they don't feel they belong can lead to civil conflict including terrorist bombings. The conflicts between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland and the actions of the Basque separatists in Spain demonstrate what can happen. If some Ukrainians decided to start a Balkans style ethnic cleansing campaign, Russia would feel compelled to invade.
I was going to include this suggestion in a post dealing with the situation in general but decided the proposal would be more likely to be noticed if suggested in a separate post. I believe the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo which ended the war between the United States and Mexico in 1848 suggests a resolution of the conflict over control of Crimea.
A dispute over whether an area (occupied by persons who identified with the United States) which is now the State of Texas was independent sparked a short war between the United States and Mexico. The United States easily won the war but then agreed to purchase another part of Mexico that was attracting settlers who identified with the United States. The purchase eliminated the potential for a future conflict between residents of that area and the Mexican government
Crimea is something of value so it would be fair for The Ukraine to receive compensation for its loss. The payment for Crimea could be thought of as compensation for money the national government of The Ukraine has spent on the region for such expenditures as government buildings or infrastructure items like roads. The payment would replace tax money that would no longer be collected from Crimea.
Payment wouldn't need to take the form of money. Russia has ample energy resources and The Ukraine already obtains energy from Russia. Thus, natural gas or some other fuel might be used as compensation. The Ukrainian government has had a policy of trying to keep energy costs down for its citizens. Russia might significantly reduce what it charges for natural gas for the next 10 - 20 years with an implication that the discount would be passed along to individuals. Russia might also offer to compensate anyone wishing to move from Crimea to the Ukraine or The Ukraine to Crimea.
Ukrainian officials need to recognize the potential costs of trying to force Russian Crimeans to stay in a country where they don't feel they belong can lead to civil conflict including terrorist bombings. The conflicts between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland and the actions of the Basque separatists in Spain demonstrate what can happen. If some Ukrainians decided to start a Balkans style ethnic cleansing campaign, Russia would feel compelled to invade.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
