Showing posts with label civil war. Show all posts
Showing posts with label civil war. Show all posts

Monday, August 3, 2015

How God Ended North American Slavery

The actions God took to end slavery in North America provide an example of the truth of the religious phrase "God works in mysterious ways His wonders to perform."

Although southern leaders in 1860 might have been upset that there weren't  going to be any more slave states,  there didn't appear to be any realistic prospect that the United States government would end slavery in the near future.   Even if there had been sufficient sentiment in the north to abolish slavery,  neither Congress nor the President had any constitutional authority to end slavery, especially if  they tried to do so without compensating the owners for the loss of their slaves.  Even if the west could have been divided into enough states to ratify a constitutional amendment eliminating slavery, such a situation would have been decades in the future.

Slavery was unpopular in the north, but northern whites didn't want slavery in their states because they  were often bigots who hated the people most often held as slaves.  Keeping slaves out meant keeping blacks out.   Northern whites might have been reluctant to end slavery without assurance that the freed slaves wouldn't move to the northern states.  

Slavery had caused the nation to become two different economic and social entities  beginning in the colonial era.

The southern colonies were solely economic entities that had found some high value labor intensive crops that could be grown for profit in the southeastern climate.  They had early turned to forced immigration of Irish and African workers to supplement voluntary immigrants to obtain the necessary labor.   The first workers were temporary indentured servants who served for several years and were then given their freedom.  Plantations later switched to having the Africans become permanent slaves.  English law didn't allow English subjects to be permanent slaves, but plantation owners got a law allowing "foreigners" [i.e., Africans] to become permanent slaves

The northern colonies drew more from religious dissidents: such as  Pilgrims and Puritans in New England and Quakers in Pennsylvania.  

The debate over slavery in 1860 reflected this difference.  Southerners viewed slavery as an economic issue. They had depended on some form of forced labor [indentured servants or permanent slaves] for 240 years and couldn't envision a different labor system for agriculture,   Residents of northeastern states viewed slavery as a religious issue in 1860, even though they had earlier sailed the ships that brought the slaves.   Residents of western states viewed it as a racial issue.  They didn't want blacks either as slaves or free people.

On the surface, the specific reasons Confederate states gave for seceding from the Union weren't  sufficient to justify such a drastic action.  There was no significant threat to the south or slavery.     However, a more general reading of the reasons indicates the leaders of the Confederate states no longer felt they were part  of the United States.  Confederate leaders felt their states were alienated from the United States.   They had unrealistic expectations.  For example, they complained about not being able to expand the slave trade to the plains and mountain states, but the climate of those areas could not have supported plantation type slave agriculture.

The slow progress of the war against the tenacious Confederate army created concerns that European powers might decide to support the Confederate states.  This situation forced  President Abraham Lincoln to gamble by issuing a wartime executive order called the Emancipation Proclamation to punish slave owners in the rebellious states by freeing their slaves.  The Proclamation could have caused the four slave states that had remained in the union to secede.   The Proclamation neutralized Britain which had been leading the effort to eliminate the international slave trade.

Prior to the war most of the states that remained in the union had prevented blacks from voting.  The length of the war angered northern residents so much that by the end of the war they were willing to "punish the southern states" by ratifying constitutional amendments to guarantee the freed slaves, and their own black residents, the right to vote and equal protection of the laws.

The protection of the rights of former slaves would remain an elusive dream for a century after the Civil War, but the war provided the only opportunity to provide the promise of a society in which skin color wouldn't matter.   It would have been difficult to have gotten the 14th Amendment ratified in 1960.  Without that amendment the civil rights legislation of the 60's might not have been possible.

The adoption of the Civil War's civil rights amendments represented a miracle as did the elimination of North American slavery.   In 1860 there was no realistic way to end slavery other than through transformation of the southern economy from an agricultural orientation to a manufacturing orientation which could have taken decades.

Confederate leaders took the only action that made elimination of slavery possible.  A peacetime president had no authority to act against slavery.   However, a wartime president could act against slavery because war creates its own reality.   If the war had ended quickly, President Abraham Lincoln would not have had a reason to act.  

The Confederate army's ability to force a lengthy war pressured Lincoln into making slavery an issue for diplomatic reasons.  The length of the war created animosity in the north against the south and a desire to punish the Confederate states.   The abolitionists were able to exploit this anger to get the northern states to forget that their own black residents would get the same rights.

I'll let readers decide for themselves.  Did North American slavery end because of a "happy accident", or did God affect the minds of those involved so that they unintentionally took the actions that would end slavery and at least potentially guarantee the freed slaves equal rights?  

Wednesday, July 8, 2015

Black Americans Should Thank Confederate Leaders for Their Rights

It is unlikely that the Civil War amendments would have been proposed and ratified if Confederate leaders hadn't precipitated the Civil War.   The fact that the civil rights amendments were an inadvertent result of the Civil War doesn't detract from the fact that the war resulted in ratification of constitutional amendments that outlawed slavery and would eventually guarantee all black Americans equal protection of the laws and  the right to vote.   Blacks should embrace the Confederate flag to show their gratitude for the benefits blacks received from the Civil War.   Incidentally I'm the great grandson of a Union army veteran and have on special feelings for the Confederate Flag". 

People should stop using the Confederate states and the Confederate flag as scapegoats for American racism.  At the time of the Civil War northern whites appear to have been far more racist than southern whites.  Slavery at the time of the Civil War was not just about color.  Although most slave owners were white, there were black slave owners.  Although most slaves were black, there were some white slaves.

The white children of female slaves also became slaves.  For example, President Thomas Jefferson's slave concubine Sally Hemings was also his sister-in-law.  Hemings, who was legally classified as white, was the daughter of a union between Jefferson's father-in-law and a slave.  Several of their children subsequently passed for white after being freed and leaving Virginia.

The strange case of Jane / Alexina Morrison demonstrates that slavery wasn't necessarily about color.  According to the slave trader who sold her in Louisiana the blonde haired blue-eyed young woman he called "Jane" was born a slave. The woman who called herself "Alexina" sued him for kidnapping her. The case bounced around the Louisiana courts just before the Civil War with juries siding with Alexina and the courts with the slave trader.  It  apparently is still technically before the courts.   Regardless of which person was telling the truth, the fact that the courts even considered the possibility of Morrison being a slave demonstrates that white slaves were a part of southern slavery.

The fact northern states prohibited slavery didn't mean they treated blacks fairly.   One of the reasons they didn't want slaves was because many northern whites were bigots.  They  hated blacks whom they considered inferior and didn't want them around regardless of whether they were free or slaves.   A northerner would have been far less likely to have had the type of relationship Jefferson had with Hemings.

"[R]ace prejudice seems stronger in those states that have abolished slavery than in those where it still exists, and nowhere is it more intolerant than in those states where slavery was never known." --Alexis De Tocqueville, �Democracy in America� 1835

At the start of the Civil War black Americans had few rights even in the states that didn't allow slavery.   Most northern states, including recently admitted Kansas, prohibited blacks from voting.  Many limited blacks to performing the least desirable jobs and living in the least desirable locations.   Indiana wouldn't allow blacks to attend school.  Illinois tried to keep them out entirely.

"When the Civil War ended, 19 of 24 Northern states did not allow blacks to vote. Nowhere did they serve on juries before 1860. They could not give testimony in 10 states, and were prevented from assembling in two. Several western states had prohibited free blacks from entering the state. Blacks who entered Illinois and stayed more than 10 days were guilty of "high misdemeanor." Even those that didn't exclude blacks debated doing so and had discriminatory ordinances on the local level."

Two Civil War era incidents demonstrate the racism of northerners and the United States government. 

On November 29, 1864, a unit of the Colorado Territorial Militia murdered peaceful Arapaho and Cheyenne women and children at Sand Creek.    Almost exactly four years later on November 27, 1868, George Armstrong Custer led a unit of the United States cavalry to murder peaceful Cheyenne Chief Black Kettle and his people on the Cheyenne reservation on the Washita River in Oklahoma territory.

The Civil War allowed Abolitionists  to gain power and push their agenda which included rights for blacks.   It is unlikely they could have gained approval for amendments guaranteeing blacks equal rights, especially the right to vote, without the Civil War.   States that didn't allow blacks to vote would have been unlikely to ratify a constitutional amendment approving that right  except as a means of punishing the southern states for the Civil War.

The southern states didn't have slavery because the white residents were racist.  Slavery developed in the early colonial period because of the difficulty of attracting farm labor.  Land owners initially used "indentured servants"  who served for a period of time before being given their freedom.  Initially most indentured servants were white, especially Irish who were forced to come to America so the English could take their land.  The first Africans arrived at Jamestown in 1619.  They were treated just like white indentured servants with some landowners giving them land after they finished their period of indenture.

Later landowners decided they would rather have permanent slaves even though that hadn't been the British practice. The fact that Africans were considered foreigners provided a loophole to treat them as permanent slaves. The color difference was a bonus that made it easier to slave from non-slave.  The idea that they might be inferior developed as a rationalization for treating them differently. 

The southern region slipped into the trap of slavery during the colonial period and no one at the time of the Civil War could figure a way to change to a different labor system.   Slaves had become a significant financial asset and abruptly freeing slaves without compensating the owners, at least in the form of some type of loans, would have been the equivalent of burning up money.   Without compensation the owners would have lacked money to rehire the former slaves as employees.  Without money the former slaves would have been unable to buy food.

Jim Downs in his book "Sick from Freedom" indicates that the abruptly freed slaves suffered
"the largest biological crisis of the 19th century".  Mass starvation and rampant disease affected as many as 1 million of the 4 million slaves.   The racism of northerners likely contributed to this crisis because many of them didn't care what happened to the former slaves..

A growth in immigration capable of  creating a labor surplus conceivably could have eventually caused a shift to paid workers by giving companies with paid workers a competitive advantage.   If a slave died the business had to purchase a new one. If a paid employee died, the company just hired someone else.  A slave owner had to continue to provide food, clothing and shelter to slaves during economic downturns to protect his investment.  Paid workers could be laid off.
 
The Confederate states decision to leave the Union wasn't just directly about the slavery issue.   The southern agricultural economy needed different economic policies, particularly on tariffs, than the northern economy.  People in the region, including some of the more knowledgeable slaves, may have developed a common identity of being victimized by the northern states because they lived in the south. They may have agreed with leaders that their states no longer had a stake in the union.   Such an attitude could explain why some blacks, both slave and free, decided to fight for the confederacy.  Slaves might have been worried that the war would replace one master with another.  They didn't know President Abraham Lincoln intended to free them until after the war.  White soldiers who didn't own slaves [
only 33% of families owned slaves] may have held such an attitude in addition to being worried about how an invading army might treat them and their property.  Some white soldiers had only limited incomes and the military service was an improvement.  Northern soldiers may have been fighting to end slavery, but southern soldiers had more complex attitudes. 

American racism has nothing to do with the Confederate Flag or the Confederate States of America.  The real racists are just trying to use the Confederate Flag as a scapegoat for their own efforts to divide Americans into phony racial categories.   Censoring the Confederate Flag or removing the statues of  Confederate leaders will do nothing to reduce racism because these symbols are not responsible for perpetuating the outright lie that black Americans and white Americans belong to different "races"

The Confederate Flag is no more inherently racist then the crosses that the Ku Klux Klan liked to desecrate by burning.  The best way to discourage the use of the Confederate Flag by racists is to convert it into a symbol of racial unity.   This action should be part of a process in which those people who had ancestors living in the south prior to World War II recognize they likely have cousins whose skin is of a different color than theirs.

Sex across the color line in the south likely began even before an African named John Punch married a white woman who was probably an indentured servant in about 1835. Barack Obama's mother was one of the descendents of this union.   In early Virginia young people often had to marry across the color lines because the number of man in a color group didn't always equal the number of women.  Later when Virginians decided to have blacks be permanent slaves, rather than indentured servants, many planters required their African male slaves to marry their white (primarily Irish) female indentured servants so the resulting children could be kept as permanent slaves.  A change in laws made a child's status as slave or free determined by the mother's status.  It was only free white women who were prohibited from having sex with black men because they children would have been free.  Some of the descendents of these mixed marriages would eventually be able to pass for white and become part of the white population.

Slavery typically includes sexual relations between men in the master class and women in the slave class.  Some of the descendents of these relationships might eventually pass for white as was the case with children of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings.   After slavery sex between white men and black women was allowed. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., had an Irish ancestor.  Sen. Strom Thurman had a black daughter by the daughter of his family's housekeeper.   These type relationships mean  many southerners have cousins of a different color.
 
Those who talk about southern racism ignore the north's own racism.  The Roberts Case which provided the "separate but equal" doctrine  for the Supreme Court's Plessy v. Ferguson decision allowing racial segregation  was a Massachusetts court case.  Lawrence, Kansas, which was a center for anti-slavery sentiment had segregated schools. 

Southern racism didn't become a serious problem until long after the Civil War.  For a brief period in the late 19th Century blacks and whites were working together politically.  Then southern white leaders began encouraging racism to keep themselves in power.  These racists received major assistance from the Supreme Court when it condoned racial segregation in the Plessy v. Ferguson case.   They later received assistance from Hollywood with the extremely racist movie "Birth of a Nation"

The Chicago race riot in 1919 in which 34 people died demonstrates northern racism in the early 20th Century.  The riot was one of many Red Summer race riots in northern and southern cities which included a lynching of a black prisoner in Omaha, Nebraska.  In 1992 the acquittal of white officers who beat a black taxi driver named Rodney King triggered a race riot.

The use of demonstrations to deal with racial discrimination began in northern cities in the 1930's with the "don't shop where you can't work" department store boycotts.  Rev. Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., led a bus boycott to force the hiring of black bus drivers in New York City.

The Board of Education in the Brown v. Board of Education case which outlawed school segregation was in Topeka, Kansas.  Wichita, Kansas, high school students conducted a sit-in to force a drug store to integrate its lunch counter in 1958.    Housing segregation remains a reality in many northern cities.  Recent controversial incidents of police killings of black men have occurred in cities that were in the Union during the Civil War. 

Northern states allow the operation of "Jane Crow" health facilities.   A "Jane Crow" health facility is a facility that primarily treats minority women but isn't as strictly regulated as facilities treating white men.  Such facilities violate federal civil rights law.  Tonya Reaves died as a result of a botched abortion in one such facility, which lacks a license to operate,  in President Barack Obama's hometown of Chicago.

Friday, May 2, 2014

Russia Should Follow U.S. Example in Eastern Ukraine

Russia should respond to the situation in the Ukraine by following the precedent set by the United States in a comparable situation.   Russia should offer to purchase the Russian populated areas whose residents want to leave Ukraine much like the United States purchased California from Mexico.

In the 1840's people from the United States had settled in parts of Mexico, but were not happy with the Mexican government.    U.S. citizens in the Texas region  had openly revolted and gained independence from Mexico.  People in California were also interested in leaving Mexico.   The United States annexed Texas and a border dispute led to war between the United States and Mexico.   The United States won the war but instead of simply taking other territory from Mexico forced Mexico to sell California and additional areas to the United States.  The United States also assumed some debts that Mexico  owed to U.S citizens.  

The Russians in the eastern Ukraine don't want to be part of Ukraine any more than the U.S. citizens in California and Texas wanted to be part of Mexico.  Russia should help them leave by offering to purchase the region from Ukraine once the people of Ukraine vote for a new government.   Government officials chosen in an election have authority from the people to act.  Officials who came to power as a result of mob action have no authority from the people to act. 

Russia should also consider compensating Ukraine for the its loss of Crimea.  The separation of Crimea from Ukraine was comparable to a divorce.  Often one party to a divorce will compensate the other by paying alimony to the other/  Russia could undermine claims that it "stole" Crimea by paying alimony to Ukraine.  Paying for something isn't stealing.

The mob overthrow of a president from eastern Ukraine and talk of eliminating Russian as an official language indicates that many Ukrainians don't want Russians in their country. The presences of racist elements in the anti-government mob indicates the overthrow may have been in part motivated by ethnic prejudice.   Russians in Ukraine fear that failure to allow the Russian region to leave Ukraine could result in use of violence against them.   

Failure to allow the Russian region to leave could lead to prolonged efforts against the Ukraine government. European ethnic conflicts [such as the Basque conflict in Spain and the conflict between Irish Catholics and English Protestants in Northern Ireland]  can last for generations.

Americans tend to think of ethnic conflicts in terms of differences in skin color, but differences in culture can produce the same results as was the case in Adolf Hitler's efforts to exterminate the Jewish people.

During the collapse of the Soviet empire, the residents of Czechoslovakia recognized that they would have a better chance of success if they split into two countries.  Ukrainians made a mistake by keeping the arbitrary political boundaries set by the old Soviet Union.   The Soviet Union to a large extent was a Russian empire.  Keeping Russian regions in Ukraine means Ukrainians are still subject to control by politicians chosen in part by  Russians.   Eliminating the Russian regions from Ukraine would make Ukrainians truly independent of Russia.